The highly-regarded global medical NGO, Medecins Sans Frontiers (Doctors without Borders), MSF, has issued a very troubling but illuminating Statement on Diphteria currently reported as ravaging part of northern Nigeria.
In the Statement (https://www.msf.org/shortages-diphtheria-treatment-put-thousands-children-risk-nigeria), MSf "warns that shortages of diphtheria antitoxin (DAT) – the critical drug for treating diphtheria ......" is a major factor "undermining efforts to control the outbreak in northern Nigeria.\", thus putting "thousands of children at risk of severe illness and death."
According to Dr David Kizito, MSF Medical Coordinator in Nigeria: “The global shortage of diphtheria antitoxin is becoming a matter of life and death..Our stocks are dangerously low, and we risk being unable to treat children and save lives as the outbreak continues.”
Two salient facts stand out in this Report by the MSF.
First, is that.Antidotes/Effective treatments for Diphtheria exist, but they are deliberately NOT being produced, globally. This should be shocking.
According to the MSF, DAT is quite effective in neutralising the toxin produced by the disease, especially when administered within 48 hours of symptom onset. However, for reasons best known to global health authorities, "global availability remains dangerously inconsistent"
In short, global health authorities, though always shouting about Diphteria, are deliberately making the sure treatment scarce and unavailable.
On the other hand, the same health authorities continue to push mass vaccination as the solution to Diphteria control. Unlike the DAT, there is no shortage at all to the vaccines. Rather, the problem is getting enough people to come get it (low immunization coverage).
Interestingly, the cost of DAT is put at about a mere ₦100 per vial (10,000 IU) while the cost of the vaccine begins at N9,660 per dose and could be as high as N56,000 per dose
Moreover, according to the report by the MSF, in Gusau, Zamfara state, "Most of the people admitted were children, and four out of every five patients had not been vaccinated". This indicated that 20% of the patients requiring treatment had actually been vaccinated.
Damning as this data could be, it does not actually indicate the true efficacy of the DPT vaccine. Actual figures are however available elsewhere.
The paper by Iwan Muhamad Ramdan et al (2018) reports on the Risk factors for diphtheria outbreak in children aged 1-10 years in East Kalimantan Province, Indonesia. The paper specifically reports that "We found that the most of the children who had diphtheria had been immunized against DPT.". Specifically 83.3% of patients presenting with diphteria had been vaccinated, compared with only 63% vaccinated from the matched controls (neighbours who did not have diphteria)
Even more instructive are the specific risk facotrs for diphteria. According to the not unexpected findings of the Study, the major risk factors are: "Poor Personal Hygiene or Nutritional Status: Infrequent bathing, low awareness/knowledge of the disease, and undernutrition...." [https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC6844134/]
The clear conclusions are thus not just intuitive, but also scientifically proven: if authorities are really concerned about diphteria, what is needed are massive efforts to PREVENT it in the first place - via good public education; and facilitation of good hygiene (adequate provision of clean water), and good nutrition. This should then be backed up by abundant stock of the sure treatment - DAT. All of these could be made available at a fraction of the cost of the "subsidized" vaccines people are being begged to receive (Paid for by government and made available free of charge to the individual)..
For a discussion on another critical aspect of the "mass vaccination" solution, the safety of the DPT vaccine, readers are referred to our comprehensive Report here.
Government is of course well aware of all the points raised in this article. However, on a "global" issue as this, the captured government structure in our "poor" country will do the right thing only in response to public outcry.
Precious lives are at stake, there is nothing so sophisticated in the DAT (or even the pure Diphteria vaccine) that they cannot be produced locally in Nigeria.
Shalom.

1 comment:
It's also important that while efforts are being made to procure the antidotes, relevant bodies such as the local and the state governments take steps to stem some, if not all, the primary causes of diphtheria. It's now open fact that the Federal Government now provides extra funds that run to billions of Naira to them,
Post a Comment